
Cordyceps Sinensis vs Militaris: Comparing Benefits, Risks, & More
|
|
Time to read 9 min
This store requires javascript to be enabled for some features to work correctly.
|
|
Time to read 9 min
Cordyceps is one of the world’s most profound species of fungi–and its potential medicinal effects as a mushroom nootropic and performance enhancer have an eternal reputation. The wild-grown version of this medicinal mushroom, Cordyceps Sinensis, can cost upwards of $20,000 per kilogram.
Needless to say, that left Cordyceps Sinensis benefits a bit out of reach for most people, so experts synthesized a new Cordyceps species that was a bit easier to grow–but what's the difference between Cordyceps Sinensis and Militaris?
When comparing Cordyceps sinensis vs militaris, the key differences lie in their origins, cultivation methods, and potential benefits. Let's dig into the details:
Table of Contents
Cordyceps Sinensis is the “wild strain” of cordyceps, but it is nearly impossible (and expensive) to obtain.
Cordyceps Militaris is the “lab-grown” version of Cordyceps, but it’s also the only variety that contains cordycepin, an active substance associated with increased benefits.
Both varieties of cordyceps may have similar benefits, including anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, antidiabetic, anti-aging effects, and more.
Cordyceps sinensis grows in the wild on caterpillars and is rare and expensive, while Cordyceps militaris can be cultivated more easily and affordably, offering similar benefits.
Both are known for boosting energy, enhancing athletic performance, and supporting immunity, but militaris is more accessible.
As we mentioned, natural Cordyceps is a parasitic fungus that typically infects the larvae of insects and transforms into a unique mushroom-like structure. This natural phenomenon led to its discovery and subsequent use in traditional medicine. Despite rumors, Cordyceps is not psychedelic, but it is valued for its potential benefits, like enhancing vitality, improving endurance, and boosting overall health.
In fact, the potential benefits of Cordyceps are expansive and may include (pending more expansive human trials):
The question we want to explore today is: what’s the difference between the rare, but naturally sourced Cordyceps Sinensis and the lab-grown Cordyceps Militaris, and do the benefits match up? Let’s talk about both Cordyceps varieties:
Cordyceps sinensis, commonly known as the caterpillar fungus, is the original and most well-known species of Cordyceps. It primarily grows in the high-altitude regions of the Tibetan Plateau and the Himalayas. More specifically, it grows parasitically, using ghost moth larvae as its host.
Traditional Chinese medicine has used Cordyceps sinensis for centuries to support respiratory health, improve kidney function, and enhance physical performance.
Cordyceps Militaris is a species that can be cultivated in controlled laboratory conditions. It is often considered a substitute for Cordyceps Sinensis due to its similar chemical composition and potential health benefits. Cordyceps Militaris has gained popularity in recent years due to its availability and ease of cultivation, making it a viable alternative for individuals seeking the benefits of Cordyceps.
So, while the two species of Cordyceps are very different in how they are produced, the way they are used and their benefits mostly line up. Cordyceps Militaris, was, after all, designed to offer consumers an affordable and accessible option to replace the benefits of the original fungi strain.
There are, of course, a few differences to be aware of when it comes to the chemical composition between the two. Specifically, there’s a difference in two active compounds: adenosine and cordycepin.
Cordyceps Sinensis has greater levels of adenosine, but contains no cordycepin. Cordyceps Militaris contains both, but lower levels of adenosine. This merely makes a difference in the degree to which each cordyceps variety helps with specific ailments and situations. Over all, the benefits are incredibly similar.
Unfortunately, there has not been any research to date to directly compare the two varieties, but we can take what we know about each one to draw close conclusions. Let’s break down the benefits:
Both varieties of Cordyceps are thought to have powerful antioxidant properties, but research suggests that there is some variation between them.
According to research, Cordyceps Militaris has a more potent inhibitory effect on liposome peroxidation, a natural process that leads to the breakdown of cells and their signaling function. According to this same study, however, the Sinensis variety is better at inhibiting protein oxidation, which is a mechanism that’s implicated in Alzheimer’s disease and other neurodegenerative diseases.
Both varieties of Cordyceps also exhibit hypoglycemic properties, meaning they can help to lower the blood sugar, which means they may be useful for managing diabetes. However, one study suggests that the Cordyceps Militaris variety is more effective in this regard.
A recent study found that both Cordyceps militaris and Cordyceps sinensis may help to relieve symptoms related to respiratory illness, but the study did not suggest a significant difference in the effects of the two varieties.
Another study found that both varieties may be effective for treating autoimmune diseases. The study suggested that both may be equally effective, but for different reasons, and seems to call for a mixed use in this regard.
The same autoimmune disease study listed above found that while both varieties of Cordyceps are incredibly similar, only Cordyceps Militaris contains a compound called cordycepin. This biologically active compound is associated with a multitude of benefits, and it's fair to say that Cordyceps Militaris may behold these increased benefits above Cordyceps Sinensis.
According to one report, the benefits associated with cordycepin include:
One reason that medicinal mushrooms like Cordyceps are so popular is because they aren't usually linked to any severe side effects. Of course, while high-quality mushroom supplements are usually safe, there are still a few potential mushroom supplements side effects to be aware of. Generally speaking, though, the risk is the same for both varieties of Cordyceps. The most common side effects may include:
Read “Cordyceps Side Effects & How Quality Impacts Risk” to learn more.
If you're looking for the short and sweet comparison between Cordyceps Sinensis benefits and Cordyceps Militaris benefits, it's simply this: Both varieties of Cordyceps have similar potential benefits, including:
However, Cordyceps Militaris is the only variety that contains cordycepin, a bioactive compound that is associated with additional benefits.
The two varieties have the same safety profile and side effects. Cordyceps Sinensis, which grows only on caterpillars in only a few parts of the world, is incredibly hard to come by and costs upwards of $20,000 per kilogram. Cordyceps Militaris, however, is much more accessible and affordable.
When looking at the facts, it's plain to see–Cordyceps Militaris is the better choice. Not only is Cordyceps Sinensis extremely rare and expensive, but it doesn't contain cordycepin, a powerful bioactive compound associated with most of Cordyceps Militaris' increased benefits.
The good news is, most Cordyceps supplements on the market are made with the Militaris variety, making Cordyceps supplements more affordable and attainable for the public.
There's more to choosing a good mushroom supplement than just differentiating between Cordyceps varieties. You also need to determine the style of cordyceps you prefer (like Cordyceps coffee vs capsules) and the Cordyceps dosage that best fits your needs.
Finally, take a good look at the overall quality of your mushroom supplements since this has everything to do with the Cordyceps Militaris benefits you will reap and the side effects you may encounter.
We'll quickly break it down:
When buying mushroom supplements, you have two basic options–mushroom powder and mushroom extract.
Mushroom powder is a ground up version of dried, whole mushrooms. It contains all of the vitamins and minerals found in the fresh mushroom, usually in similar ratios.
Mushroom extract, on the other hand, is a concentrated version of the bioactive compounds (in this case, beta-glucans and cordycepin) found in the mushroom. Mushroom extract, which also often comes in powder form, allows you to consume powerful doses of beneficial beta-glucans without needing to consume copious amounts of powder.
Next, you also have to look at the source of the extract you choose. Some products are made from mushroom mycelium while others are made from fruiting bodies.
Mycelium is the underground “root” portion of the mushroom, and while it is important to the mushroom life cycle, it does not typically contain a high concentration of bioactive compounds. Typically, mushroom extracts made from 100% fruiting bodies are the best choice for medicinal use.
You can learn more by reading “Mushroom Powders vs Extracts” and “Mycelium vs Fruiting Body.”
Looking for a high-quality Cordyceps Militaris supplement? Consider pairing Cordyceps with other medicinal mushrooms and botanical nootropics for the ultimate brain and body awakening.
Our Lucid mushroom+nootropic formula contains a hearty dose of Cordyceps, plus other mushrooms and nootropics, including:
This synergistic mix is designed to enhance cognitive capacity while improving cellular energy and endurance so that you feel good inside and out. Read "Why We Chose Our Ingredients: What’s in a Lucid Stack?" to learn more. Or check out one of our three flavor varieties:
Cordyceps militaris is often considered better for supplementation due to its higher concentration of active compounds like cordycepin. Cordyceps sinensis, while traditional and valuable, is rarer and often more expensive, with variability in potency.
The best form of Cordyceps depends on your goals. Extracts and powders are typically the most potent and convenient, while capsules offer an easy, consistent dosage. Tinctures can also be effective for quick absorption.
People with autoimmune diseases, those on blood-thinning medications, and individuals with certain hormonal conditions should avoid taking Cordyceps militaris without consulting a healthcare provider. Pregnant or breastfeeding women should also seek medical advice before use.
Some studies suggest that Cordyceps sinensis may support testosterone levels and improve sexual function, but more research is needed to confirm these effects. It’s not a guaranteed method for increasing testosterone.
The downside of Cordyceps can include potential side effects such as digestive issues, dry mouth, or an allergic reaction. Additionally, its effects on the immune system may not be suitable for those with autoimmune conditions.
Side effects of Cordyceps sinensis may include mild digestive discomfort, nausea, diarrhea, and, in rare cases, allergic reactions. It's generally well-tolerated but should be used with caution by those with underlying health conditions.
“Comparison of Protective Effects between Cultured Cordyceps militaris and Natural Cordyceps sinensis against Oxidative Damage” https://pubs.acs.org/doi/pdf/10.1021/jf053111w
“Hypoglycemic activity of the fungi Cordyceps militaris, Cordyceps sinensis, Tricholoma mongolicum, and Omphalia lapidescens in streptozotocin-induced diabetic rats” https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00253-006-0411-9
“Effects of Cordyceps sinensis, Cordyceps militaris and their isolated compounds on ion transport in Calu-3 human airway epithelial cells” https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0378874108000524
“Cordyceps as an Herbal Drug” https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK92758/
“Cordycepin for Health and Wellbeing: A Potent Bioactive Metabolite of an Entomopathogenic Medicinal Fungus Cordyceps with Its Nutraceutical and Therapeutic Potential” https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7356751/